On the Record

I write it down so I can’t pretend I didn’t know.

I’ve never trusted the answers people give to the question of why they write. Most of them sound right, but none of them feel entirely honest. “I write to express myself.” “I write to understand.” “I write because I have something to say.” All of that is true, but it doesn’t hold up for very long. It’s the kind of answer that sounds better the less you look at it.

Writing is a strange thing to claim as private. The moment it leaves your head, it isn’t. Even if no one reads it, it’s shaped as if someone could. That quiet implication of a witness has always bothered me more than I could easily explain. It’s like setting a place at the table for someone you insist isn’t coming.

I’m not going to pretend there isn’t a reader somewhere in the background. There is. There always is. If nothing else, it’s the version of me that comes back later and decides whether what I wrote was honest or not. He’s not especially kind to me, but he’s consistent.

I’ve learned not to trust thoughts that stay in my head too long. They get comfortable in there. They move the furniture around and start acting like they own the place. Feeling is worse. Feeling makes a case out of whatever is loudest in the moment and calls it truth, usually with more confidence than accuracy. It doesn’t allow that. It forces a shape, and most things don’t survive that.

I write to find out what’s still standing after it’s been forced to take form. Most of what I think disappears the moment I try to put it into words. It turns vague, or dishonest, or smaller than it felt a second ago. That tells me something. It means it wasn’t solid to begin with.

There’s a temptation to clean it up after that—to make it sound better than it is, more coherent, more complete. The danger is subtle. You start sanding the sentence until it no longer catches on anything. It looks cleaner. It also stops being true. It’s a polite way of lying to yourself in complete sentences.

I try not to do that. Not because I think writing should be raw or unfiltered—that’s just a different performance—but because I’ve learned what happens when I do. The sentence reads better. It also isn’t mine anymore.

There’s another part to it that matters just as much. Writing puts something on record. Not who I am on a good day, and not who I can explain myself into being, but who I’m willing to stand behind when it’s written down. Once it’s there, I don’t get to move it without noticing. I don’t get to quietly revise myself without leaving a trail. The words sit there, indifferent to my mood or my excuses. They hold me to a version of myself I chose on purpose. Not perfectly, and not permanently, but enough that I have to answer to it.

Publishing it doesn’t change the reason. It just removes the hiding place. Once it’s out, I don’t get to stand next to it and explain what I meant or correct how it lands. It either stands on its own or it doesn’t.

There’s a part of me that wants it to be seen. I’m not going to pretend otherwise. But I’ve learned not to trust that part very much. If something needs to be seen to matter, it probably doesn’t. And if it can be seen and still hold its shape without me standing behind it, then maybe it was worth writing.

So I write it down. Not because writing makes me better than I am, but because it makes it harder to pretend I didn’t know who I meant to become.

Leave a Reply

Is this your new site? Log in to activate admin features and dismiss this message
Log In